Letter No. 12: Before the Horses

Selena and I spent Labor Day laboring.

We had the address of the family’s forty-acre property and knew the names of the two gravel roads that met at its corner. Our GPS knew the roads too. What it could not seem to decide was which of the two corners belonged to the address we had entered.

There is something familiar about a washboard gravel road. Its evenly spaced ridges feel like evidence of trucks and cars traveling faster than the surface was willing to allow. Our tires rattled across them, the vibration traveling through the truck as we slowed near the intersection and looked from one property to the next.

The valley between Laurel and Red Lodge opened around us. Hayfields seemed to flow into one another, their boundaries difficult to distinguish from the road. Beyond them, the Beartooth and Absaroka mountains held the horizon, large and unmoved above the smaller human efforts taking place below.

Then we saw the fencing. Rough coils lay on the ground at intervals along the fence line nearest the road. They looked like supplies waiting to be used.

We knew we had arrived.

A mother and her two adult daughters had begun removing the old fence in the days before Labor Day. That morning, the five of us put on gloves, gathered the tools, and began the day’s work together. Their progress made one thing clear before we ever touched the wire: Selena and I had not arrived to provide the determination needed to finish the project. They already had plenty of that.

We had simply come to help.

Forty acres arranged in a square comes with roughly a mile of perimeter. Around most of this property, that perimeter was marked by five strands of old barbed wire. We would spend the better part of the day helping remove fencing along three of its sides.

From the gravel road, the strands nearly disappeared into the hay. Up close, the fence had the stubborn presence of something that had been standing for a long time. Rust had claimed nearly every length of wire. Some sections were bent, some were broken, and others were missing altogether. Posts leaned in different directions, as though the fence had slowly stopped agreeing with itself.

It clearly needed repair. Broken strands could have been replaced. Leaning posts could have been straightened. With enough time, effort, and new material, much of the fence could have been restored to something closer to what it once was.

It still would have been barbed wire.

The family was preparing the property for horses, and the old fence was not the boundary they wanted around them. It was not coming down simply because it was damaged. It was coming down because what might still have been repairable was no longer suitable for the life being prepared there.

The horses had not arrived, but their needs had already changed the answer.

So we began.

Rusty wire under tension has a voice. Pull it, and it hums. Move it against a post, and it vibrates with a low metallic note. Cut it, and the released tension travels along the remaining length before answering with a sudden twang.

As we made our way along the fence line, the wire provided a rough, almost melodic soundtrack. Notes rose from the hay ground whenever a strand was lifted, pulled, adjusted, or freed from whatever had held it in place.

The melody was not entirely gentle.

Barbed wire does not care which side of it a person is standing on. Even after it has been cut and pulled loose, every few inches contains another sharp point waiting to introduce itself. By the time we left that afternoon, my arms looked as though I had gotten into a fight with a bobcat.

The bobcat won.

Some stretches of wire came free in long strands we could guide toward the trailer. Others collapsed into loose balls that looked like the aftermath of an abused fishing reel—the kind of hopeless backlash an angler might stare at for a few seconds before cutting off all the line and starting over.

Except this line was made of steel, and every few inches it had teeth.

Rolling barbed wire did not make it safer. It simply gathered all the danger into something portable. There was no obvious handle, no harmless side, and no direction from which to approach without finding another barb pointed toward you. Move one loop, and three others seemed to tighten. Free a sleeve, and the wire caught a glove.

Every part of it objected to being handled.

All five of us did whatever the work required. We cut wire, pulled it free, loosened sections from posts, wrestled snarled strands into coils, lifted whatever came down, and carried everything we removed to my trailer. No one stood back waiting for an easier assignment.

In fairness, there were no easy assignments.

Working beside the mother and her daughters, I began to notice how naturally they moved through the work. When one task was finished, they found the next. When a section of fence resisted, they changed their approach and kept going. If something required another set of hands, one of them stepped forward before anyone needed to ask.

At one point, as we struggled with one of the worst coils, the three women reminded me of the warriors from the island Wonder Woman comes from. If those warriors had traded their armor and swords for leather gloves and fencing pliers and opened a fencing crew in Montana, they might have looked something like this.

Their strength was not theatrical. It was practical. It appeared in shoulders carrying wire, hands reaching for tools, and the absence of any suggestion that the hardest part of the work should belong to someone else.

The shared posture of the three women seemed too deeply established to have begun with this particular fence. Their mother took hold of the difficult work, and her daughters took hold beside her. Whatever lessons had passed between them over the years no longer needed to be repeated aloud.

We often imagine formation happening through instruction—a parent finding the right words and a child remembering them. But example can be practiced so faithfully that, by adulthood, the lesson no longer looks like a lesson.

It looks like instinct.

A difficult thing appears, and no one asks whose responsibility it should be. They simply begin deciding where to place their hands.

The property represented a new beginning for the family. The house needed repairs, but for now they were content living in a twenty-four-foot trailer while preparing the land for their animals. Comfort and function inside the house mattered, but creating the right environment outside it came first.

The house could wait a little longer.

The fence could not.

That priority stayed with me. The family was not simply walking around the property repairing whichever broken thing happened to be nearest. They were working backward from the life they intended to build. A future that had not yet arrived was already establishing the order of the present.

The horses needed a safer boundary. That need determined which project came first.

I began thinking about the difference between repair and replacement. Repair asks whether something can be restored. Replacement asks whether it is still suitable for what comes next.

Those are not always the same question.

Much of life depends upon our willingness to repair what has been damaged. There is honor in mending what can be mended rather than abandoning it at the first sign of wear.

But usefulness is not the only measure of whether something should remain. A structure may still be standing. It may even be repairable. Yet the future we are preparing for may require something different from the structure that served us before.

We can reinforce it, straighten it, and replace its missing pieces, only to discover that we have carefully restored something designed for a life we no longer intend to live.

The old fence could have been repaired.

It still would have been the wrong fence for the horses.

By about three o’clock, we had worked along the better part of three sides of the property. My trailer, which had been empty when we arrived, now held coils of rusted wire and everything else we had removed. The barbs had not become any friendlier simply because they were no longer stretched between posts. Even gathered on the trailer, loose ends still seemed capable of reaching out for one final scratch.

Selena and I left the trailer there when we headed home.

From farther back, the valley again looked open and nearly uninterrupted. Hay ground moved visually from the family’s property into the neighboring fields, while the Beartooth and Absaroka mountains remained beyond it all. With long sections of the old fence gone, it was difficult to tell exactly where their forty acres ended and the neighboring land began.

When we arrived that morning, coils of fencing along the road had confirmed that we had found the right place. When we left, my trailer held much of the boundary that had once defined it.

Most of the new fence was not yet standing, and the horses had not arrived. Still, their future presence had already changed what could remain, what needed to be replaced, and which work came before comfort.

Before the horses, there was a mother and two daughters taking hold of a difficult thing together—as though we can do this had been practiced so long that it no longer needed to be said.

Until next Sunday…

George

If this letter reminded you of someone, perhaps send it to them.

I hope you’ll stay awhile and read a few more. And if you’d like future letters delivered to your inbox, I invite you to subscribe.